Women would be happier if _____.
Fill in the blank! But not too creative with your answers because everyone knows women only want to stay home and raise children because working makes them super unhappy.
This morning as I was sipping the latte I bought with an adult colleague, I happened upon The Raw Story’s piece on Gavin McInnes, the founder of Montreal-based Vice. McInnes laments the unfortunate evolution of women in the work-force – we’re all so unhappy! We should be at home makin’ babies and shutting the hell up.
You know what makes me happy? Not getting evicted because my job means I can pay my rent each month.
Feminism is awesome; it has made it so I could do cool stuff like go to university and vote.
You know what makes me unhappy? How much it costs to send my kid to daycare so I can go to work and make the money I need to not be homeless. Also, insufferable hipster douchebags, but that’s kind of a given.
That women are unhappy in the work-force is a thing women in the work-force hear a lot about. An informal poll of the women in my office revealed that none of us are unhappy in the work-force – it certainly beats being home with the kids all day (which is not to say that staying home with kids is inherently lesser – it just means it’s not for everyone) – but we would prefer if someone came around with snacks at scheduled points throughout the day.
I like my job. I find managing projects and solving problems and reading Buzzfeed lists on my lunch break tremendously fulfilling, and while my little moppet sure is charming, I am not fulfilled by responding to his every whim and fancy. You can pay people for that! People even go to school for it.
I am less happy because it is 2013 and misogyny – and rape culture, and slut-shaming, and mansplainers – is still a thing we’re dealing with.
McInnes claimed that “men are the majority of breadwinners in the Western world,” and that “women are forced to pretend to be men. They’re feigning this toughness. They’re miserable. Study after study has shown that feminism has made women less happy. They’re not happy in the work force, for the most part.”
Um, if I am pretending to be a man … why the hell am I wearing Spanx? The only thing I’m “feigning,” if anything at all, is that I have the capacity to do everything that’s required of me day in, day out – and that includes having a social life and making meals and occasionally cleaning the bathroom if I remember. I’m not miserable; I’m effing tired. My job is where I go to relax, son. There are trips to Starbucks and adult conversation with people whose interests mirror my own. THANK YOU FEMINISM!
Feminism is awesome; it has made it so I could do cool stuff like go to university and vote. It’s also really helped out as far as allowing my family to keep up with the breathtaking cost of inflation and life on the west coast. I have a job! And a credit card!
I am not less happy because of feminism; I am less happy because I am a millennial who came of age during a time when many of the opportunities my parents had are disappearing or long gone. I am less happy because anytime I complain about the cost of childcare, someone invariably tells me “you shouldn’t have had kids if you couldn’t afford them.” (Haha, thanks! Just let me go back in time and fix everything.) I am less happy because it is 2013 and misogyny – and rape culture, and slut-shaming, and mansplainers – is still a thing we’re dealing with.
“Why are all you wimps complaining that violence is bad, ‘macho’ is bad,” he said. “That’s how we got here. This idea of this beta male being in control is, what, 20 years old? You’re going against 40,000 years of evolution.”
I’m not miserable; I’m effing tired
Yes, idiot: violence is bad. “Macho” is a narrow and dated interpretation of masculinity. And evolution is like feminism in that you get a lot of things out of it that you didn’t have before, like flush toilets and the smallpox vaccine and Cheetos. Cultures evolve. Masculinity evolves. Hopefully we’ll get to a point where women are not still considered property in so many parts of the world.
As for not having children at all, McInnes says “Seven percent of them, I guess, like not having kids.” That means 93 percent of those of us with uteri are like “ZOMG! KIDS!” and I can vouch for the fact that’s not the case. Women are complex individuals! They are not all interested in the same thing! It’s almost like they’re people.
urbanmoms says
Fabulous post, Emily. This is one of those stories where I wonder, “Did this guy say this just to get a rise out of everyone? Is he an attention whore and that was his whole strategy? Or, worse, does he actually believe this sh*t?”
Alice says
I love my job. And my kids. And friends. And hobbies. And going out and having fun. And I suppose I would probably like having a clean house if I knew what that looked like. and no, I can’t do those things all at once. But I can certainly try and glean what I can of all of them in an ever-shifting balance that does leave me stretched thin and tired, but ultimately, I wouldn’t want to cut any one of those things out of my life entirely, so I do what I can. Like we all do. Our balances, and the things we put at the top of the list change all the time, but everyone finds their own way, and they sure don’t need asshats like this to oversimplify it for them.
Also, I love this. “flush toilets and the smallpox vaccine and Cheetos.” YES.
Kat Clarke Murray says
ARGH! Why is there so much of this kind of garbage floating around the internet these days? It seemed cliché and old-fashioned to say, “biology is not destiny” when I was in university back in the 80s, but it looks like we need to crack the old slogan out again and beat this arsehole around the head with it.
Eileen says
Hahahahahahahaa. So it’s black and white, eh? Either I yearn to have my womb full of parasite fetuses (fetii?) all the time so I can stay home with them, or I don’t want them at all so I can work and be happy sans procreating? Is that what that person was trying to say? Why can’t I want both, or neither? I guess I’m a bad female, thinking for myself and all.
Emily Wight says
STOP DOING THAT. THERE ARE NO GREY AREAS.